2012 Review of On-Premises Small Business Accounting Programs

• What is the one thing that you intended to do each year but just can’t find the time to resolve the issue,
• Do you want to increase marketing, organize your office, update internal controls, or gain remote access?
• Will you need to integrate your business management software with other applications?

Let’s take a look at the software packages reviewed and examine how they meet the needs of your business and many other small businesses.

Basic System Functionality – All the packages were reviewed on a PC running Microsoft Windows. Installation of each package was completed without issues and each program was up and running in just a matter of minutes.  General Navigation & Ease of Use was also addressed; all of the products reviewed used a forms oriented interface rather than requiring the user to understand debits and credits (with the obvious exception of journal entries). The appearance of the screen and use of navigation techniques, availability of dashboards and customizable menus varied. Industry Specific features were included in some programs including industry specific versions and/or reports. Platform support was also noted, and while all of the products reviewed are available in a version for Microsoft Windows, only a few support other platforms, such as MacOS or the mobile operating systems installed on most tablets and smartphones.

Accounting Capabilities – All products contained core accounting capabilities such as a general ledger, accounts receivable, and accounts payable functions. Likewise, the applications all had some support for Sales Tax, including the ability to consolidate rates for multiple jurisdictions, but none were able to support value added taxes like those levied in Canada or the European Union. Payroll functionality varied significantly, and while all reviewed products supported in-house payroll preparation, some also offered integrations with other providers, such as payroll service bureaus. Audit Trail Reporting was included in all programs with various report options.  Multi-Currency abilities were included in some programs with various methods for updating rates. Unfortunately none of the programs reviewed included options for Multi-Language Support. All of the programs offered Multi-User capabilities but few had options within the program for Multi-Location support of offsite data entry.

Day to Day Operations –Significant differences were found in Sales, Point of Sale, and Shipping features. Although some programs included advanced features, and add-ons, and others offered integration with other products, and finally, some did not support any specific capabilities. Customer, Vendor and Employee Management was included with all products with the ability to e-mail invoices and perform a mail-merge for collection letters. Some products included advanced functionality with Customer Relationship Management integration or add-on products. Inventory and Purchasing varied considerably among products, and we considered the major functions in this area, including inventory valuation, multi-location capabilities, bill of materials, and reporting.

Management Features – Many programs included Dashboard Overviews to give management a snapshot of the company’s status. Reporting was also considered to identify the customization capabilities, integration with third party report writers or ODBC access, and support for exporting built-in reports to multiple file formats. Security was also reviewed to determine if individual or role based security. Establishing user rights can be complicated and it was important to understand how these rights were established and if they related to menu options, general ledger accounts or any other type of group.

Integration, Import and, Export – Programs allowed various degrees of import capabilities including lists, budgets, and transactions. Generally batch processing systems allow greater import functionality due to the ability to import to an unposted batch and then use the normal posting procedure When integrating two systems, it is important to have a pre-built integration or the option to import transactions; therefore both of these options were analyzed. In addition to importing data, integration with third party applications and portals to increase productivity and enhance Customer Relationship Management (CRM) abilities was also considered in this review.

Help & Support – All the programs included impressive help and support options. Some programs required access to the internet to read help files, and most had videos available (either on CD or online), and US based telephone support. All of the vendors offered support plans for additional guidance and payroll tax table updates. Additional support was found on websites, user groups, community bulletin boards, and consultant networks.

We have also provided an Executive Summary with pricing to highlight the features that we feel are most significant for each product. Please continue on to read individual reviews with a list of strength’s, potential limitations, star ratings, and best fit of each product reviewed.